Celebrity

Editing Tweets Is a Bad Idea


Editing Tweets Is a Bad Idea
Image: Getty

Today, Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey took questions from Twitter users about what they want the company to do better in 2017. Dorsey seemed receptive to one idea that Twitter’s power users have been begging for: the ability to edit tweets. This is an awful idea.

With the rise of fake news, trust in things posted online is at an all-time low. So why would Twitter add a feature that might make a user second guess what they’re reading? If a your tweet has a typo or an error, there’s a super easy way to fix it: just delete it and repost the tweet. If you were able to edit a tweet even minutes after sending it, you could easily trick a lot of people. More specifically, tweets with breaking news can be retweeted hundreds of times in just a matter of minutes, so if someone was to change a tweet after it has been retweeted 300 times, things could get messy.

Maybe Twitter could solve this by adding an icon to indicate that the a tweet has been edited, but then how would you know to what degree it was edited? Twitter could add a revision history in order to combat this, but 140 character tweets with a revision history attached seems excessive. And what if a crucial piece of information is subtly changed so that it modifies the entire meaning of the tweet? And what if you retweeted some sentiment that you agreed with, only to find that the tweet you just endorsed has been changed to mean something entirely different? I could go on.

Editing tweets would be an easy way for sloppy reporters to spread misinformation and sew confusion or for trolls to spread falsehoods. Here’s a hypothetical scenario: a reporter tweets about a gunman at the intersection of Green Street and Third Avenue. The tweet is retweeted and shared hundreds of times in just a few minutes. But then, the reporter realizes he misheard the police scanner and realizes there was no gunman at all. So he edits the tweet, leaving little trace of the original error—unless Twitter imposes that clunky revision history feature that users would probably ignore.

In theory, editing tweets sounds nice, especially for quickly correcting typos, but there is no conceivable way to build a tweet editing feature that wouldn’t somehow lead to misinformation or even be abused. Part of the brilliance that Twitter useful is knowing that the tweet you’re seeing can’t been modified. Changing that principle would make Twitter even more confusing and less reliable.

If this hasn’t convinced you that editing tweets is a terrible idea, try out this fun thought experiment: what kind of shit would Donald Trump pull if he was able to edit tweets?

Click to add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Celebrity

More in Celebrity

xzntje6n10fnrmntxlbe.jpg

Isabelle Huppert Repulsed By Clothes On Her Own Back

StaffFebruary 24, 2017
gbsyrytwzk7mqnwnae3d.jpg

Report: Over 700 People Were Detained During the First Weekend of the Travel Ban 

StaffFebruary 24, 2017
t91si1x8czk1hgvkbd1c.jpg

Gabby Giffords to Texas GOP Rep Louie Gohmert Who Refused to Hold a Town Hall: 'Have Some Courage'

StaffFebruary 24, 2017
n4navkttnw2b8ywd81id.png

An Explainer of the Lesbian Drama on This Season of Real Housewives of Atlanta

StaffFebruary 23, 2017
puzzgsxnfhulh8h7fu6b.jpg

Rihanna Is Getting Harvard University's 2017 Humanitarian of the Year Award!!

StaffFebruary 23, 2017
lvd7i6rwkwr4mklxuh1y.jpg

Protestors Arrested at Dakota Access Pipeline Camp as Deadline to Evacuate Expires

StaffFebruary 23, 2017
po8dhizo9tghig0xa7gm.jpg

Just Because a Movie Took a Long Time to Make Does Not Make That Fact Noteworthy

StaffFebruary 22, 2017
o82nesnpazr5s99xaq8s.jpg

Judge Blocks Texas from Cutting Planned Parenthood Funding from Medicaid 

StaffFebruary 22, 2017
vte0c4xtmyubmjvga7mu.jpg

Imagine a Reboot of The Hills Featuring the Kids of the Original Cast

StaffFebruary 22, 2017